Skip to toolbar

Best Collision Vs Best Comprehensive car Insurance with its variations

Your annual auto insurance premiums are substantially improved by collision and comprehensive vehicle insurance. What will be the difference? When is extra coverage worth paying for? And when is it possible to cancel?

A common aspect of most auto insurance plans is accident and comprehensive coverage. But precisely what they are is something of a mystery to most drivers. There are times when you need collision and thorough, and other times when it’s just a needless cost. That’s unfortunate.

What is collision coverage?

As a result of an accident, the primary objective of crash coverage is to protect you for car injury. In all collisions that are your fault or another driver’s fault, colliding would protect you.

As a rule, crash insurance will pay for the car’s repairs. But in cases where the repair cost is more than the vehicle’s book value, the car will be “totaled,” and you will only be paid by the insurance provider for the book value of the car. At that point, you will have the option of either fixing the vehicle for less money than originally expected. OR using the money to fully rebuild the vehicle.

If the negligence of another driver is the cause of the damage to your car, your crash coverage may sometimes pay to repair your vehicle and then demand compensation from the insurance carrier of the other driver. In the case that the other person’s insurance carrier is difficult to deal with, it would be a fair compromise. Generally speaking, if the other driver is at fault, the insurance premium would not be affected by the allegation.

For hit-and-run collisions where the car sustains injury, crash compensation can be used. But you cannot decide the identity of the other driver. In reality, collision also protects you from harm caused by uninsured drivers.

What is comprehensive coverage?

The form of auto insurance covering automotive damage caused by accidents is comprehensive insurance (as opposed to collisions). Comprehensive insurance also covers other vehicles that you drive.

Incidents subject to comprehensive insurance include harm caused by:

  • Vandalism
  • Theft
  • Floods
  • Fallen objects

What particular events are covered is explained by your detailed rider. For this purpose, to ensure that the most common risks can be protected, you should always be sure to read the part of your policy.

Your vehicle will be protected for just about any possible disaster that can arise between crash and comprehensive auto insurance.

Why do you have full and collision-free auto insurance?

You might be reading this and you might be thinking: is that not what car insurance is for? Replacing my car if it’s a complete accident?

Yes, in part. But several drivers have car insurance plans that do not provide adequate coverage and crash coverage. The most important forms of auto insurance pay for harm to other vehicles and drivers that you cause. For instance, if you cause an accident and kill another driver, the driver’s medical costs will be covered by your car insurance. And even if you don’t have crash coverage for your own vehicle, the cost of fixing the other driver’s car might be protected by your car insurance.

In auto insurance plans, these important provisions are why most states require drivers to carry automobile insurance.

Related: Minimum coverage needed by any state for auto insurance

Furthermore, the bank normally mandates that you bear accident and comprehensive insurance if you finance or lease your vehicle. However, the cost-benefit analysis of buying the extra insurance policy is up to you until your vehicle is paid-in-full.

There’s a lot of controversy as to when the crash and comprehensive auto insurance should be cancelled. This is an important issue because the combination of the two has a huge impact on the cost of the premiums for your auto insurance. That’s not always the best thing to do, though.

When you should consider dropping collisions and comprehensive coverage

You would be fully on your own if you need to fix or replace your car as a result of an accident or an injury as soon as you cancel your crash and extensive coverage. If you have the financial capital based on its book value (which you can review online through Kelly Blue Book) to cover the repair or replacement of your vehicle, then you will be able to remove the coverage without worry.

The 10% rule

As a rule of thumb, when the cost of the extra premium approaches 10% of the vehicle’s book value, you should consider dropping collision and comprehensive.

Example: If your car’s book value is $2,000, $200 will be 10 percent of this. It may be time to consider dropping this coverage if you pay $230 a year for collision and extensive.

But if you do, you can take banking the savings seriously as a reserve against potential maintenance or eventual replacement.

Related: Concepts of automobile insurance: What every driver needs to know

When the collision and comprehensive coverage should not be cancelled

This could be an even more significant factor than determining when the coverage should be dropped.

The general thought is that when the value of your car falls to a level where the cost of the additional coverage is not justified by the amount of gain you can get in case the vehicle causes serious harm, you should cancel accident and comprehensive. This is an over-generalization, however.

For any vehicle that has a credit attached to it, you are expected to have accident and comprehensive coverage. And even though your car’s just worth $3,000, if it secures a loan for even $500, you’ll be allowed to have the extra coverage.

From a financial point of view, if you can save, say, $600 per year to cover a vehicle that is only worth $2,000, it might make abundant sense to cancel accident and comprehensive. And that makes sense-but only if, if it is lost, you have the $2,000 to fix or replace your car. You’ll be better off holding the extra coverage if you have no cash reserves.

There is another case in which it is best to keep the crash comprehensive: when you have a history of injuries, and maybe even reckless driving. If that is the case, then it is a sucker’s bet to cancel the extra coverage. Sooner or later, you’ll get into an accident that needs compensation, and if that result is possible, it’s best to have it available.

You will lower the cost by raising the deductible if you plan to retain the collision and extensive coverage. The deductible can be raised as high as your cash reserves would allow. For example, you can easily increase your deductible to $1,000 if you have more than $1,000 in liquid savings, without raising your risk.

Where to get your insurance

These days, there are a lot of great choices for car insurance, but I want to make special note of one, Gabi. For a great price, they use the current strategy to shop around. Whatever type of insurance you have, while also enjoying the same deductibles, you can lower your premiums. Gabi’s affiliate insurers sell both comprehensive and collision insurance, so any new policy you select will cover whatever you have on your current policy.

Liberty Mutual, I’ve discovered, also makes it easier without paying extra money to completely protect your car. To provide just the coverage you need, your policy is personalized. For example, if you want accident forgiveness, that’s an add-on, as simple comprehensive features such as crash injury, the well-being of yourself and passengers after an accident, and a collision while driving a leased vehicle are important. You can combine collision and detailed coverage in a manner that makes sense for your lifestyle and budget by customizing your strategy.


Collision coverage covers for car damage caused by collisions, while any other vehicle damage, such as burglary or flood damage, pays for extensive coverage.

If you have an unpaid car loan or rented the car, you will have to carry accident and comprehensive car insurance. (You can decide whether you need to pay for comprehensive and accident coverage if you own your vehicle directly.)

Cancelling comprehensive and collision insurance makes sense if:

  • Comprehensive and collision insurance annual premiums surpass 10 percent of the book value of your vehicle and
  • In the event of a failure, you have the cash available to fix or replace the vehicle.

Until taking the plunge, thoroughly consider the costs and advantages of canceling your crash and robust coverage.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply